The first thing we check for verification is the analytical solution since we have one available. Then, we do a mesh refinement and use a smaller pseudo-time-step to check whether the results are consistent with the original calculation. By using a finer mesh and a smaller pseudo-time-step, we investigate the effects of truncation error caused by spatial discretization and temporal discretization. Then we will do a case comparison for the results obtained after spatial and temporal refinement.
The analytical solution is contained in the following file showing the concentration (or equivalently, the temperature) at various radial locations.
In addition, here are the analytical solutions for
Analytical alpha 1 and Analytical alpha 1.5
It is always a good habit to check that the mesh is refined enough. For example, you could use an element size that is half of what was used in the videos and compare the results.
When using pseudo-transient analysis, it is important to make sure that you are using a small enough pseudo-time-step. For example, you could use a pseudo-time-step that is half of what is used in the videos and compare the results, or you could also use one that is twice as big as what is used in the videos.
This tutorial is made with great help and support from Dr. Rajash Bhaskaran, Cornell University.